This letter was written by me to Editor of TOI ( never published by TOI) sometime in early 2005 on the atrocious handling of Lawyers by Lucknow Police.
Police Vs Lawyers
I had just finished my daily Prayer and was about to take first sip of my morning tea, I switched on my TV set. One of the TV channel was showing breaking News: Advocates & Police clashes in Lucknow- the city of Nawabs. The news appeared more curious & concerned to me as I myself belong to a family of Lawyers.
TV screen was showing the fight going on between Advocates of Avadh Bar and the Lucknow Police. Stones & bricks were being used as missiles by both sides. The way Policemen were chasing & beating the Advocates was atrocious and a blot on democracy. It also raises a question of the discipline of our police. At the same time Advocates should give a thought on their deteriorating status in the Society.
All said & done, Policemen’s appeared that they were behaving like criminals & hooligans in Police uniform. Charging Lathis on Professionals is not part of any civilized society and Police need to be reminded of this.
City District Magistrate and SSP were like silent spectators and were helpless to control the fury of the mob. Police officers were seen telling Constables not to hit the Advocates but all in vain. Constables were seen defying orders of their bosses.
Advocates later wanted to meet the Chief Minister but were again Lathi charged. Just now another breaking news has come that Mulayam Singh Yadav has given directions for enquiry into the whole matter, another political gimmick to keep the issue at bay. He is more busy with issues like Madarsa & dinners for MPs!
The humiliation that has come to the Judicial family needs nothing less than suspension of each & every Police personnel upto the lowest rank involved in the incident, an apology by the District Magistrate to all the Advocate fraternity.
This will convey the message to each & every Police personnel that they need to act as per the instructions of their superiors and not by their emotional charge. It appears from the video clippings that police personnel are taking their personal revenge with the Advocates.
At the same time it is high time that Advocates also clearly define their discipline code of conduct. Civilized behaviour is needed from all parties to avoid such future incident. Else, the whole world will continue to get a chance to see such ignominious incidents happening on the land of the world largest democracy.